Highly Interactive & Engaging Educational Speaker

Teens overestimate substance use: 2 in 3 high school seniors had no alcohol, nicotine or marijuana in the past 30 days

 

Sober Thoughts · For school leaders

Most Students Aren’t Doing It. So Why Do They Think Everyone Is?

Most teens aren’t vaping, drinking or using marijuana. But teens overestimate substance use among their peers, and that gap is where a lot of bad decisions start.

Ask a room of high school students one question: “How many kids in this school vape, drink, or smoke weed?”

You’ll hear “everybody.” Or “like, 90%.” Somebody in the back will say “all the seniors,” and half the room will nod.

Then show them the real numbers, and the room gets quiet.

I’ve watched this happen in a lot of gyms and auditoriums. Students aren’t lying when they say “everybody.” They believe it. And that belief does more damage than most of us realize.

The real numbers

Students who didn’t use anything last month

Every year since 1975, the National Institutes of Health has funded a national survey of teens through the Monitoring the Future study. The most recent results (December 2025) looked at students who had not used marijuana, alcohol, or nicotine in the past 30 days:

91%
of 8th graders
82%
of 10th graders
66%
of 12th graders

Even among seniors, two out of three hadn’t used any of the three in the past month. Nicotine vaping, the one everybody “knows” everyone does, came in at 9% of 8th graders, 14% of 10th graders, and 20% of 12th graders over the past year.

That isn’t “everybody.” In most schools, it isn’t even close.

Why it matters

When teens overestimate substance use, the guess matters

Researchers led by Mitchell Prinstein and Geoffrey Cohen found that teens overestimate substance use among their peers, consistently guessing too high on how much classmates drink, use drugs, and smoke. They also underestimate how much their peers study and exercise.

Then they followed a group of 9th graders through 11th grade. The students who overestimated how much the popular kids were using showed steeper increases in their own cigarette, marijuana, and alcohol use by 11th grade.

Students weren’t only copying what their friends did. They were copying what they thought their friends did.

— Robert Hackenson Jr.
The framework

Where does “everybody” come from?

When I talk with students about decision making, I start with a simple idea. We make decisions using knowledge, and knowledge comes from three places:

Formal education

What you learn in school.

Personal experience

What you’ve lived through.

Outside influence

Everything else: friends, family, social media, movies, marketing.

That third one is the loudest. It’s where “everybody does it” lives, and it’s the main reason teens overestimate substance use. A student sees a few classmates vaping in a bathroom, a video of someone they follow, a show where every party has a red cup in every hand. None of that is a survey. But it adds up to a picture, and the picture feels like fact.

When parents hear me, I put it this way: “Oh, everybody does it.” No, not everybody does. That’s glorified. What students see is the highlight reel of risky behavior, not the 66% of seniors who didn’t use anything that month. Nobody posts that.

The moment

The split-second decision

This matters most in the moment I spend the most time on with students: someone holds something out and says, “Here, you want to try this?”

A student in that moment isn’t calmly weighing the research. They’re thinking about who’s watching and what those people will think. If they believe everyone in that circle already does it, saying no feels like the strange choice.

But everyone else in that circle is mostly worried about how they’re coming across. Every teenager is the main character in their own movie. And a good share of the people standing there are probably among the majority who don’t use at all.

When a student knows the real numbers, “no” stops being the weird choice. It becomes the normal one, because it is the normal one.

Try this

Three things to do this week

  1. Run the guess before the reveal. In advisory or health class, have students anonymously guess what percentage of students their age haven’t used alcohol, nicotine, or marijuana in the past month. Then show the real numbers. The gap starts the conversation.
  2. Ask “Where did that number come from?” Have students trace their guess back to its source: a friend, a post, a show, an ad. It builds the habit of questioning outside influence instead of absorbing it.
  3. Send the numbers home. Parents overestimate too. Share the numbers in your next family newsletter with one line to use at dinner: “Most kids your age aren’t doing this. What do you think makes it seem like everyone is?”
Your turn

What number would your students guess? And what is that guess doing to their choices right now?

Give your students the real picture

Sober Thoughts helps students see what’s actually normal and think through the split-second moments before they happen, delivered with magic, illusions and humor so the message lands. Classroom curriculum and parent resources keep it going after the assembly.

FAQ

Why teens overestimate substance use: common questions

What percentage of teens don’t use drugs or alcohol?

In the 2025 Monitoring the Future survey, 91% of 8th graders, 82% of 10th graders, and 66% of 12th graders said they had not used marijuana, alcohol, or nicotine in the past 30 days.

Why do teens think everyone is using substances?

Teens build their picture of “normal” from what they see: friends, social media, movies and marketing, all of which over-show risky behavior. Research by Prinstein and Cohen found that teens overestimate substance use among their peers, and they do it consistently.

Does correcting misperceptions help prevention?

Teens who overestimated peers’ substance use went on to increase their own use more over time. That makes accurate numbers, and teaching students to question where their assumptions come from, a useful part of prevention.

R
Robert Hackenson Jr., MBA, CAOL

Robert is a prevention educator and “edutainment” speaker with 20+ years presenting to schools, parents, colleges and companies in 49 states. He uses magic, illusions and humor to teach how decisions really get made in the moment.

Sources
  1. National Institutes of Health. Reported use of most drugs remains low among U.S. teens (Monitoring the Future, December 2025).
  2. Stanford Graduate School of Education. Misfit or Miss Goody Two Shoes? Study shows misperceptions abound among adolescents (Prinstein, Cohen et al., Developmental Psychology).